Review: Carolina
Despite being named after a
State (like her siblings), the title character (Julia Stiles) has turned out
rather normal, all things considered. Her grandmother (Shirley MacLaine) is
somewhat eccentric but has been good enough to raise all the kids of her wholly
irresponsible, womanising drunk son (Randy Quaid, natch). Stiles, meanwhile, is
having problems at work (she works for a TV dating game show hosted by
seriously weird Alan Thicke), when she meets a Hugh Grant-ish type who was one
of the show’s clients, until he realised he’d much rather date Stiles. This
upsets Stiles’ best pal and neighbour Alessandro Nivola (quite charming).
Nivola, a ghost writer for famed romance novelist Barbara Eden (yes, Barbara
Eden playing a queen bitch!) has pined for Stiles a helluva long time now, and
is jealous of the new competition. This all sounds totally original, doesn’t
it? Not! Mika Boreem is irritating as Stiles’ horse-riding, phony-accent
sporting younger sister Maine (yes, Maine. Oh, how funny!…whatever). Azura Skye
plays the pregnant other sister Georgia. Jennifer Coolidge is well-cast as the
slutty Aunt.
A good cast doesn’t even come
close to saving this well-meaning but totally run-of-the-mill Marleen Gorris
romantic-comedy/drama from 2003. The romantic angle is totally predictable, and
the family scenes seem like leftovers from “National
Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation”. Quaid doesn’t exactly do his Cousin Eddie
schtick here, but it is kind of like a straight version of the role he
amusingly played in “ID4”. He’s fine
as always, but the character is sorely underdeveloped (Coolidge, meanwhile,
might as well have not turned up, well-cast as she is, she’s given nothing to
do). In fact, the entire cast is good here (“Growing Pains” dad Alan Thicke provides some laughs as perhaps the
cheesiest game show host of all-time. He’s dressed like Eric Idle in the
“Galaxy Song” segment of “Meaning of
Life”), though Boreem’s faux-British character is pretty grating.
It’s as if director Gorris (“Antonia’s Line”) and screenwriter
Katherine Fugate expected the wonderfully talented cast to make more of the
story and characters than is actually on paper. But when you’re starting with
bugger-all, even the greatest cast ever assembled wouldn’t be able to make
something out of nothing.
Rating: C
Comments
Post a Comment