Review: The Third Man

***** SPOILER-HEAVY REVIEW. PROCEED WITH CAUTION *****  Joseph Cotten plays Holly Martins, an American writer who comes to post-war Vienna for a job offered to him by his old buddy Harry Lime (Orson Welles). Unfortunately, when he arrives he’s informed that Harry has suddenly died in an accident. Military policeman Maj. Calloway (Trevor Howard) immediately takes a disapproval to Martins’ arrival in Vienna, and suggests he vamoose back home swiftly. However, two things keep Holly sticking around; 1) A beautiful local woman who knew Harry (Alida Valli) whom Holly is romantically fascinated with, and 2) The nagging suspicion that there’s more to Harry’s death than meets the eye. The longer he stays in Vienna, the more Holly’s nagging suspicion grows. Bernard Lee plays a Sergeant, Wilfrid Hyde-White plays the head of a literary society keen to get Holly to make an appearance, and Ernst Deutsch plays a suspicious-looking Austrian acquaintance of Harry’s named Baron Kurtz.

 

I’ve had a couple of cracks at this critically beloved 1949 flick from director Carol Reed (“Our Man in Havana”) and screenwriter/author Graham Greene (“Our Man in Havana”, Fritz Lang’s “Ministry of Fear”), and I’m still not really gaga over it. I think it’s time for me to accept that this isn’t going to be one of those times when I especially share the critical consensus. As with “Casablanca”, I like it but I don’t love it. There’s plenty to enjoy, particularly the extended cameo by Orson Welles and the unforgettable zither score by Anton Karas that gives the film life, energy, and personality. The shadowy, Dutch-angled, Oscar-winning B&W cinematography by Aussie-born Robert Krasker (“Brief Encounter”, “Libel”, the highly underrated “El Cid”), and use of the post-war, bombed-out streets of Vienna also give the film character. I need more than that though, and the lack of interesting characters or a compelling plot stop this one from being great in my view. The central mystery has just never grabbed me on any viewing occasion.

 

Joseph Cotten is one of my all-time favourite actors and an extremely versatile one. However, as good an actor as he is, he’s not able to make the rather bland Holly Martins a compelling lead character. He’s never anything less than solid, but he’s played far more interesting characters over the years (Particularly in “Citizen Kane” and Hitchcock’s “Shadow of a Doubt”). I think the story was meant to be the drawcard here, not the lead characters. So it’s a shame neither category compelled me all that much. Alida Valli isn’t even a terribly great performer like Cotten, and her character did even less for me here than Cotten’s. Her performance is just OK at best, nothing terribly memorable. The supporting performances by a young-looking Trevor Howard, a young-ish beret-wearing Bernard Lee, creepy-looking Ernst Deutsch, and more briefly Wilfrid Hyde-White (who was seemingly never young) are top-notch. However, it’s Welles you’re going to remember here and sadly he’s not in the film until the final third. Welles eventually became an overweight, hammy bore (even in “A Touch of Evil”, another OK but overrated ‘Great’ film), but here he makes every second count in a great, cynically evil performance. His big speech (devised by Welles himself during filming, apparently) is frightening in its casual delivery from Welles as he tries to rationalise the irrational and abhorrent. Harry Lime is truly diabolical, and he and his big speech/amorality deserve to be in a much more interesting mystery/noir plot.

 

There’s a lot to like here, it’s still a solid film, it’s just that I seem to be the only one to not regard it as a masterpiece. A great-looking, great-sounding film full of flavour, but I can’t say I especially cared about anyone or anything in the story until it perks up in the final third. It’s strange, because the spy/thriller genre is one that normally would appeal to me, and I love a lot of 40s and 50s cinema. It’s worthy of a recommendation, but I think Hitchcock (“The 39 Steps”, “Foreign Correspondent”) and Fritz Lang (particularly “Ministry of Fear”) did this sort of thing a lot better than Reed and Greene have. Critical consensus has this as one of the greatest movies ever made, so see it and judge for yourself.

 

Rating: B-

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Hellraiser (2022)

Recovering junkie Odessa A’zion accompanies scuzzy boyfriend Drew Starkey on a break-in where all they find is a weird puzzle box. A’zion later opens the box and after some weird shit happens, A’zion and Starkey figure it might be a good idea to learn more about this messed up trinket. Goran Visnjic plays a millionaire who possessed the box before our protagonist nicked it.   Is there any point in remaking/rebooting “Hellraiser” when the 1987 adaptation of Clive Barker’s original text was written and directed by Barker himself? And is considered a horror classic? On evidence here, absolutely not. Directed by David Bruckner ( “The Signal” ) and scripted by Ben Collins ( “The Night House” ) and Luke Piotrowski (ditto) this is an entirely tedious affair. I took a long time to get on board with the 1987 “Hellraiser” , I have to admit. It was wildly imaginative and original, like a nightmare transplanted on to film. However, the characters were stone cold and left me similarly chilly t
Read more

Review: Boyka: Undisputed

Yuri Boyka (Scott Adkins) is out of prison and fighting for a living, with ambitions for the ‘Most Complete Fighter’ to make a real name for himself. However, after an opponent dies during a fight, the deeply religious Boyka starts to have a crisis of conscience. He tries to make amends with the man’s widow, which eventually pits him against a local gangster (Alon Moni Aboutboul, quite good). Anything with Scott Adkins will generally get me interested, and although this series peaked with the superlative “Undisputed II: Last Man Standing” , this 2017 film from director Todor Chapkanov (director of the SyFy movies “Copperhead” and “Ghost Town” ) is no slouch in a series yet to deliver anything less than solid entertainment. Producer Isaac Florentine is missed in the director’s chair, but Chapkanov gives us at the very least the series’ most dramatically ambitious entry, as Adkins’ ‘most complete fighter’ Yuri Boyka continues on his journey to redemption here. In this one, the
Read more

Review: Ninja 2: Shadow of a Tear

Scott Adkins is once again Casey, an American proponent of the martial art of Ninjutsu. When Casey’s pregnant Japanese wife (Mika Hijii) is rubbed out, he’s on a vengeance mission to find her killers. A friendly face, Nakabara (Kane Kosugi) turns up at the funeral, and suggests Casey come to Thailand to deal with his grief in another country. Casey initially declines, but eventually takes Nakabara up on his offer. However, his wife’s murder still haunts Casey, and with intel supplied by Nakabara, the trail eventually leads Casey to a brutal drug baron named Goro (Shun Sugata).   I was extremely disappointed with the first “Ninja” , but had heard that this 2013 sequel from director Isaac Florentine ( “Undisputed II: Last Man Standing” , “Undisputed III: Redemption” , “Ninja” ) was a damn near masterpiece of the martial-arts action movie genre. Having now finally gotten my hot little hands on it, I’d say the hype is a bit much, but this is unquestionably a much better film than the f
Read more